Debate: Is social commerce a second chance to get ecommerce right?

Topic: As social commerce rises, is there a second chance for
Australian brands that lagged on ecommerce?

 

 

 

Jodie FoxJodie Fox
Director of fashion and founder
Shoes of Prey

Affirmative – There is an enormous opportunity for Australian brands that are only getting online now.

Brands don’t have to learn from scratch. Mature online markets like the US and UK provide those new to online with an enormous wealth of learnings to take advantage of that is published or easily observable. There is also a reasonable amount of generosity of time and knowledge between entrepreneurs offshore – all you need to do is ask.

There’s still a long way to go. I believe that there is an extraordinary amount of innovation to occur in the way brands engage online. The power shift from broadcast to dialogue is still very much in its infancy from both branding and resource points of view. Resource is a tricky one to crack – scalable, personal communications in every instance are not easy to manage as you grow.

There are new opportunities all the time. There is a constant stream of new online social touchpoints for brands to be present for their customers that can yield really exciting results – whether purely branding, community building or conversions. Take Pinterest, for example.

There’s something great to sell. Research shows that Australian consumers shop online to gain convenient access to goods/services – especially those that aren’t easy to obtain here. There are plenty of unique, exciting brands that are currently geographically confined, even domestically. There’s an amazing opportunity to access the greater domestic market, and then the world.

The real risks that exist with respect to Australian brands and ecommerce are, first, engaging in ecommerce without having considered why you would do it for your business and, second, running in the other direction and not engaging with it at all.

 

Karson StimsonKarson Stimson
Founder and director
WeAreDigital

Affirmative – Social commerce or no social commerce, Australian brands and retailers (whether already online or not) need to play to their advantage of being local. They need to start investing in digital services and talent, and start focusing on lifting the quality and depth of their offering.

There is no doubt that Australian brands are coming off the back foot when it comes to digital commerce. Currently 25% of Australian online retail is done offshore (38% in apparel). The Australian consumer has already become less loyal to Australian brands and is demanding premium service, quality, speed and a wider choice of range. Unless our retailers get this right, Australian customers will continue to take their dollars off shore.

Three key factors in this are:

Availability. Large format international retailers like Best Buy and Walmart are offering 10 to 25 times their product range online compared to what they have available in-store. In comparison, some of our largest retailers only put 10% of their product online.

Convenience: Those local retailers with bricks and mortar have a great advantage and need to leverage this in combating the international leakage by offering a compelling omni-channel experience where a customer can access products and service wherever and however they want. When internationals are able to land their goods here in 24 to 48 hours, and offer free returns, a much broader product mix and overall slicker experience, our local players need to lift their game.

Price: While the Aussie dollar is so strong it makes buying overseas very compelling. This requires a solid pricing strategy as shoppers are savvy and price conscious.

The real advantage of social commerce is in enhancing an existing commerce offering. It enables brands and retailers alike to leverage the power of community, word of mouth and advocacy. It needs to be done well, truly supported and embraced by the business (Best Buy, Sephora and Burberry are all great examples of this). But it is definitely not the silver bullet for the latecomers.

We would advise they focus on visibility, product availability, convenience, service and leveraging the advantage of being local.

 

Peter NoblePeter Noble
CEO
Citrus

Affirmative – One of the most exciting things about being in the online retail space at the moment is the innovation taking place in the sector both here and overseas. At Citrus, we certainly don’t believe the ship has sailed for those ecommerce laggards in Australia yet. There’s still time to embrace the fundamental change in consumer shopping behaviour we are witnessing, and social commerce will certainly play a role in this in the years to come.

The advantage of being late to the party is the lessons that have been learned by the pioneers can now be applied to the newcomers’ ecommerce strategies. F-commerce was heralded as the next big thing in online retail, but this hasn’t come to pass, with a number of high profile retailers including Nordstrom and Gap shutting down their Facebook storefronts due to poor take-up.

However, opening a storefront within Facebook isn’t social in itself. What successful social commerce is really about is giving customers the tools they need to support the social interaction that surrounds the shopping experience.

We’ve seen great innovation in this space take place in Australia, with Sportsgirl’s ‘virtual mirror’ a good example of a retailer tapping into buying behaviour, by giving its customers the ability to garner opinion from their social networks on whether they should buy a garment direct from the changing room.

For those Australian brands that have lagged on ecommerce, social commerce does not offer the silver bullet. Australian retailers must first get the basics right: world-class ecommerce sites, mobile, the establishment of one-to-one relationships with consumers, fulfilling orders in a way that’s convenient and cost-effective, and the use of customer service as a key driver of loyalty.

It’s not too late for Australian retailers, but innovating and responding to the needs of the customer are key to making a success of online retail.

 

David OdgersDavid Odgers
Director, sales and marketing
eBay

Affirmative – The emergence of social commerce, coupled with the rise of mobile commerce and continued growth of online commerce, represents a significant opportunity for Australian brands to go to where their customers are and engage with them in relevant ways.

Australians are keen to share their brand experiences with online communities, as we’ve seen with the rise of Facebook, Twitter and Pinterest. Globally, eBay is experimenting with product innovations in this space. For example, in the US, a social commerce app has been developed for Facebook that shows eBay product recommendations based on the user’s social data. Social networking sites house a substantial amount of data that can be used to provide targeted brand experiences for every consumer. Before brands embrace the opportunities for engagement via social networking sites, however, businesses need to ensure they have explored ecommerce and mobile commerce to its full capability.

We know Australian ecommerce is continuing to experience exponential growth, with eBay’s top 2000 Australian sellers growing revenue by a phenomenal 45% in 2011. More interestingly, our 2012 Online Business Index revealed that seven out of 10 online businesses believe mobile commerce will play an important role in their business strategy this year.

Australia has the third highest smartphone penetration globally, and eBay Australia has the highest proportion of total sales coming from mobile devices among all eBay marketplaces globally. It’s estimated that in four years’ time, more people will use their mobile to access the internet than desktop computers. This means that there are potentially more hours in every day that people choose to shop.

Already, we’re seeing that four million Australian smartphone owners are using their phones to compare prices and research products before making a purchase, and over a million of those use their mobile phones to purchase an item. It is the mobile device that continues to blur the line between online and offline, as the focus centres on providing the best end-to-end experience for customers.

Social commerce will increasingly play a role in how brands reach new and existing customers, but businesses need to ensure that this is part of a complete digital strategy to enable commerce.

 

How to make the most of your social commerce insights

In this guest blog, Steve Hurn, CEO at Reevoo, shares top tips on making social commerce work for your company.

 

Social commerce is an evolving term. However, despite its multiple applications in business today, most people in the digital world appreciate that ‘social commerce’ refers to any user-generated content that influences the buying process. Social commerce is where people (and sometimes also brands) assist fellow consumers in making purchasing decisions, thus enabling the commerce process in a way that is organic and based on real-life user experiences. It encompasses anything from comments posted on an online forum or social network, to opinions shared on a retailer’s website. The bottom line is that it’s all based around user reviews and user-generated content. This is what makes up social commerce.

Many brands are now gathering a significant amount of user-generated content due to their digital activities, whether this is information gleaned from their fans on Facebook, followers on Twitter, or customers who have bought a product and then left a review on the site. This information provides a wealth of insight into what customers think about the products, the brand and the service received. Despite this plethora of useful information, many brands are not yet using the information gathered through digital and social activities effectively as they could be.

In order to make the most of the insights available to them, companies can and should start thinking beyond simply ecommerce and towards the bigger picture associated with user-generated content and its benefit to a brand. The three areas where user-generated content can add value to a business are by aiding analysis of customer sentiment and profile, promoting positive interaction with customers or prospects, and by allowing the company’s different departments to streamline their operations by sharing valuable information into customer feedback. Below, we’ve identified three steps that brands can employ to make the most of social commerce. In particular, the points below outline how user-generated content can be most effectively utilised to gain key insight from potential and existing customers:

Step one: Analyse the insight you’ve gathered

1. At its most basic level, insight gained from social digital activity can be a simple barometer for brands to see how much positive versus how much negative feedback they are getting online. This feedback can be easily measured and tracked simply by focusing on what your customers are saying, capturing the top-line data from their feedback and leveraging the information appropriately.

2. Taking this one step further, brands can tag all the qualitative data acquired from verified customers, creating a data set based on customer feedback, which has quantitative value and allows for quick analysis. For example, words like ‘love,’ ‘happy,’ ‘wrong,’ or ‘disappointment,’ can be separately tracked to gain insight into how actual customers feel about a certain product.

3. Should there be a problem with a product or service, companies can leverage real-time feedback acquired through social commerce to respond to individual customers and address the issue quickly, pre-empting any potential crisis situations – something that would be impossible to do by only relying on market survey data after the fact.

Step two: Get personal

4. The Internet, and particularly social networks, provide us with immediate and easy communication channels. Thanks to them, brands, customers and prospects alike now have a direct line of communication – one which companies stand to benefit from. Customers can be thanked for a nice comment, tweet or picture, comments can be responded to personally and the brand ‘voice’ communicated in real time. Ultimately, utilising this form of social communication shows that there is a ‘human touch’ behind your brand, which demonstrates a receptivity and caring approach towards customer feedback. Taking an online, real-time communication approach increases personal connections with customers, and, therefore, garners goodwill among consumers.

5. Enable productive communication by providing a platform for your customers and prospects to exchange information between one another. Then, get interactive with your customers and join that conversation as appropriate. Social commerce can be used for Q&A – either between the customer and the brand, or to connect two or more people who have purchased a product. This not only helps customers with queries about a product, but you will gain a greater understanding of where the pain points are in the buying process.

Step three: Look at the ‘bigger picture’

6. Make the content generated from social commerce work smarter for you by leveraging the content that is created from user-contributed feedback. User-generated data gleaned from social commerce, including positive quotes and reviews, make great marketing collateral in addition to providing useful insights into areas that can use further development.

7. Reach out wider in to the online social ecosystem to integrate the content your users are generating with Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn or Pinterest. This allows you to help customers and prospects no matter where they are. For even more sophistication, build tracking into these links, so you can see where content has been shared and how many times, allowing you to improve your communications and thank your advocates.

8. Social commerce insight can be analysed on its own, in a variety of ways that suit each business. But, to take the data gleaned from social commerce insights a step further, a company can look towards integrating it with existing CRM and other data-aggregating systems. In this way, a company can use social content for the benefit not only the sales departments but also those for marketing, customer service and technical support.

 

Understanding and using the above tips in the ways that are best suited for your individual business will allow you to leverage social commerce, demonstrating to the wider business the value of digital and social activity.  Furthermore, a solid social commerce strategy will ultimately help you to engage with and understand your customers better, leading to a better customer experience and, hence, increased sales and loyalty.

 

Facebook to roll out ‘want’ button for products in news feed

Rumours of a ‘want’ button on Facebook have been confirmed with the social network announcing it is testing a feature that will allow users to declare their intention to buy products featured in pictures.

Facebook announced that it has joined forces with seven retailers – including Pottery Barn, Victoria Secret and Neiman Marcus – to test a platform which allows users to ‘want’, ‘collect’, or ‘like’ a product, according to Mashable.

The button will be attached to images designed to be discovered in the news feed, which appear for non-followers of the brand when their friends like an image. Users will be able to click want to signify to their friends they would like to own the product and click through to buy the items via Facebook.

The feature, dubbed ‘Collections’, has a Pinterest-style look with images displaying individually or in groups. It appears that for grouped images the want button will hover over the corner of each image, while for individual images it will appear underneath.

After clicking ‘want’, users will be given the option to comment on what they like about the product.

Presumably a move to encourage more brands to invest on the network since its IPO, the initiative could see so-called ‘F-Commerce’, which is yet to gain traction, kick into gear.

The button will not extend off Facebook through the web the way social plugins, such as the ‘like’ button does, instead being an action restricted to the Facebook platform. In a statement sent to AllFacebook, the social network said:

“We’ve seen that businesses often use pages to share information about their products through photo albums. Today, we are beginning a small test in which a few select businesses will be able to share information about their products through a feature called Collections.  Collections can be discovered in news feed, and people will be able to engage with these collections and share things they are interested in with their friends. People can click through and buy these items off of Facebook.”

No word on when the feature will go public has been released.

Images source: Business Insider.

Bad reviews are good for business, boost conversion

Online retailers have nothing to fear from bad reviews and should embrace them for their trust building and feedback value, says Reevoo, the latest provider of product review architecture to launch in Australia.

In fact, bad reviews can be one of the most effective conversion tools for a content marketer, according to Reevoo’s research, which found that consumers who read negative reviews have a 67% higher conversion rate than those who don’t.

Having recently opened an office in Australia, Reevoo provides social commerce services centred around reviews, similar to those provided by global reviews giant BazaarVoice. The company refuses to allow its clients, which number almost 200 and include blue chip names Ford, Black & Decker, Orange, and Sony, to delete negative reviews.

CEO of Reevoo, Steve Hurn, explains that even the best product or service will have drawbacks in the eyes of some, citing the iPhone’s breakability and dubious call quality as an example. “If you go on to Amazon or TripAdvisor and see five out of five reviews one after the other, it’s boring, it’s unrealistic… consumers don’t trust it,” he says.

Hurn says he’s lost only two clients over a two year period for refusing to allow negative reviews to be removed. Most of the brands he works with are apprehensive at the beginning but come around once they see the benefits of being transparent. As well as building trust, negative feedback can help improve product design, marketing and customer service, and even help brands turn detractors into brand advocates through good customer service.

Of course, generating more positive than negative reviews is the end game for retailers looking to build the consumer’s voice into their product pages. But many are opening themselves up to a high ratio of negative feedback by making little effort to solicit reviews. Anger or disappointment are usually the strongest spontaneous motivators for leaving a review, and by failing to proactively seek reviews positive feedback will often go unsaid.

Hurn says the company is expanding quickly and has recently closed a round of funding to allow it to compete internationally. He is currently hiring sales and marketing staff locally and hopes to have a team of over 10 based in Australia by March next year.

 

The death of discounting: P2P marketing trend ‘social gifting’ hits Australia

Social gifting – the act of giving a gift voucher or the like to a friend online and a trend that could replace discounting strategies with peer recommended financial incentives – has landed in Australia.

Leader of the pack in what’s being billed as the next shopping phenomenon, Wrapp, launches locally today, enabling users to give Facebook friends free and paid gift cards from retailers including Lorna Jane, Industrie, Speedo, Roses Only and Booktopia.

A range of other retail brands have also signed on for the Australian launch of the app which promises to deliver highly sort after word of mouth and mobilise buyers in a similar way to discounting strategies minus the negative impact on brand health associated with slashing prices.

Co-founder and chief operating officer of the service, Carl Fritjofsson, says the retailers Wrapp has worked with overseas, which include big name players Gap, Sephora and H&M, have been surprised to see how high redemption rates are for the vouchers.

“Some retailers compare similar offers that they send through email newsletters, such as a similar $10 voucher,” Fritjofsson told Marketing. “The industry standard open rate for emails is usually a maximum of 30% then usually the conversion is in the small single-digit percentage. A good EDR [electronic direct response] campaign would convert 1%-2% max. For all of our gift cards we see a 10-15% redemption rate… that’s an indication that the third party endorsement is huge.”

Since launching in November 2011, Wrapp users in seven countries have sent over 2.4 million free and paid gift cards. Users of the app see a list of Facebook friends who they can choose to send free gift vouchers to (usually of $5 or more depending on the brand) or pay for a higher value voucher from a list of available brands. Participating retailers can choose demographic segments to target, and a value per gift receiver to cap free voucher outlay per user. So far results across Wrapp’s merchants place the yield from each sale at between four to six times the value of the free gift card awarded.

Wrapp takes its revenue from a flat fee for free vouchers redeemed and a percentage of the value of paid voucher redemptions. Initially launched in Sweden the service has since rolled out to the United States, United Kingdom, Germany, the Netherlands, Finland, Norway, with Australia set to become its eighth market.

The venture is backed by Atomico, the London-based venture capital firm started by Skype co-founder Niklas Zennström, and Silicon Valley-based Greylock who’s partner Reid Hoffman co-founded the social network, LinkedIn. A host of other startups, like CashStar, SocialGift, Groupcard Apps and DropGifts, are also rushing to capitalise on the trend.

Fritjofsson believes the system has the ability to cash in on, and expand, the $2.5 billion a year Australian gift card sector. It leverages one of the key occasions that Facebook users connect around – reasons to celebrate such as birthdays, engagements and other milestones or achievements. In doing so, it enables retailers to disguise discounting strategies as peer to peer gifting while at the same time generating a story on Facebook about the brand gifted and driving higher conversion rates.

We’re seeing real, profitable sales being driven through this performance based tool,” Fritjofsson says. “When the retailer realises this could be considered more a discounting strategy than a marketing strategy; it’s not $100,000 in marketing spend it’s actually $100,000 that would come from the discount budget, that’s when we see retailers start to use it like a drug.”

Apple is also shaping up to play in the space also with its ‘Passbook’ app, which houses boarding passes, tickets and loyalty cards, and looks to be the precursor to a mobile wallet for the iPhone, set to launch as part of the upcoming iOS6 release.

Fritjofsson says there are no plans to integrate Wrapp into Passbook, but that it may well happen in the future.

 

Qantas to leverage social commerce with accommodation site Hooroo

Qantas has created a sub-brand to sell accommodation via social media in an attempt to capitalise on travellers who book after seeing friends post about their trips online.

‘Hooroo’ is the first travel site to integrate social discovery and sharing with the ability to book accommodation directly at destinations Australia‐wide, the airline claims.

Head of marketing for the new venture, Lija Wilson, says the rise of social commerce led Qantas to develop a platform that integrates content, social and the ability to transact in a seamless user experience. “Travel is the most social of all categories – we all ask our friends for inspiration and suggestions and then share our experiences through our networks when we get back from a trip,” Wilson says. “Our launch strategy is centred around seeding the brand via social channels and then allowing travellers to take that real‐life behaviour online.”

hooroo

In addition to its initial focus of social seeding, Hooroo will launch with a digital campaign created by Badjar Ogilvy Melbourne. For the campaign a group of consumers were charged with the task of developing 24‐hour itineraries for destinations around Australia, which will be shared through hooroo.com, as well as their own blogs, Twitter accounts, Facebook pages and other social outlets.

The initiative gives Qantas a road into the high margin, high growth online accommodation market and leverages off the back of Tourism Australia’s launch of ‘There’s nothing like Australia’ domestically.

Research from Tourism Australia shows that social media is rapidly impacting the way Australians travel domestically, with 20% having booked a domestic holiday as a result of viewing their friends’ social media updates.

Tourism Australia chief Andrew McEvoy threw his support behind the site. “We know that compelling destination content and competitive deals can play a big part in stimulating people’s desire to explore and travel, and the creation of the new Hooroo social travel site seems to embrace this insight, which we’re hoping will inspire more Australians to reconsider their own backyard and take the next step by booking a domestic holiday or getaway,” he said.

 

Top10 uses of social commerce

As far as buzzwords go, they don’t get much fluffier than ‘social commerce’. The term is used to describe any online activity that gets consumers talking about products or buying them in a social setting. It’s basically a way of saying shopping is, and always has been, a social undertaking and if we can get people shopping in a social manner online we can utilise the influence of word of mouth in ecommerce.

As a result, this catch-all term encompasses a range of techniques. It can manifest as a brand awareness or building tool, via campaigns that encourage consumers to talk about brands, review or recommend them. It can come in a direct response marketing form, via encouraged sharing of discounts or offers on social media. It can be built into a retail site itself, through social recommendation functions, like Amazon is famous for, or onsite reviews. Or it can even be to do with how the transaction is completed – group buying is often classified as social commerce and selling through social networks is growing in popularity.

Not confined to online operators, social commerce is being leverage by traditional retailers with programs designed to socialise bricks and mortar. Using the social graph to engage consumers wherever they may be, creating more personal, accessible experiences, and amplifying word of mouth can all be grouped under the social commerce umbrella.

Start-ups and agencies are emerging, providing software and platforms for brands to execute on social commerce. This Top10, presented in no particular order, looks at some examples of social commerce in action, and some of the best platforms out there which epitomise the approach.

Coca-Cola, Facebook store

Just as they do offline, retailers are gravitating towards highly trafficked areas online. Rather than hoping for customers to come to them, they’re going to the spot where over 800 million consumers are not only spending their time but sharing their opinions, recommendations and in some cases making purchases – Facebook. Not as many seem to be involved in f-commerce since Facebook updated its Pages format to the Timeline layout, but some notable success stories, such as Coke, are going strong.

With a big brand name behind it and a well-designed storefront to generate trust, Coke has found a global market place for its merchandise products, extending its product line outside of beverages in a serious way.

 

Chirpify

Chirpify turns Tweets into transactions, enabling consumers and businesses to buy, sell, donate and transact in-stream on Twitter. It claims to be device agnostic and frictionless, allowing consumers to make payments in one step and in real time.

Once signed up with a verified account, Chirpify removes the frictions of a traditional payments or e-commerce system, transforming Twitter from a broadcast platform into a transactional one. To transact users tweet simple commands such as ‘buy’, ‘pay’ and ‘donate’. For brands the process is simple. First, create and tweet your offer with a product image. Second, shoppers reply with the word ‘buy’, and if they’re registered, the transaction is automatically processed. Users can connect their PayPal account so the money is automatically deducted as they shop. The system has also been used by charities and political campaigns in the US.

 

Shopon

Shopon integrates into ecommerce sites, enabling the retailer to encourage sharing of purchases and products to Facebook. Coupons and other incentives offered on the retailer’s site encourage customers to share, and time-limited sales and gamification mechanics can also be administered. The software tracks clicks, Facebook posts, comments and likes, and the sales that result. Data collected via the retailers signed up for the service showed that for every 100 shares on Facebook, 123 visits were made back to a retail site and 10.4 sales were made. A study conducted by Shopon in May also found that gaining traction from encouraged sharing on Facebook is becoming increasingly difficult, with clicks per link shared declining from 3.6 in May 2011 to 1.2 in May 2012.

If you can’t see the video below, please refresh this page.

 

Bazaarvoice

Bazaarvoice, a global social shopping agency, offers a platform that integrates ratings, reviews and queries into ecommerce sites. Providing reviews on site has proven successful in giving shoppers the confidence of having a third party recommend the product, and also provides the brand with an opportunity to engage with users and learn from their feedback. The tool also enables brands to syndicate reviews across channels, mobile and social. For example, reviews posted on Saba.com could be shared on Saba product pages on Myer’s website also.

 

Amazon

The online retail giant is the master of social recommendation, thanks in part to the number of customers it boasts who’ve connected via Facebook. Looking at your Facebook friends, it will provide birthday and gift suggestions, popular titles, favourite books, music and movies.

 

ShoeDazzle

ShoeDazzle was one of the first to add the like button to the products on its site and within the first month had thousands of likes for its top products. The women’s shoe retailer also lets people login to its site using Facebook, with Facebook-connected users 50% more likely to make repeat purchases every month than average shoppers, according to SearchEngineLand. The site has since added the ‘Pin it’ button so that users can share products on Pinterest, and pulls in recommendations from Facebook friends.

 

Macy’s

Macy’s Magic Fitting Room featured a large-scale mirror that interacts with a tablet and lets customers browse, shop and try-on clothes virtually. Shoppers can send their favourites from the virtual fitting room their Facebook pages to get feedback from friends, or save them to refer to in the store.

 

Eventbrite

Event ticketing company Eventbrite has revolutionised the ticket sales model of Ticketek by introducing social. Eventbrite’s motto is ‘events are inherently social’. When people buy tickets for an event, they want to share the experience – and the news – with friends. The social web fuels the conversation and the communities that arise around live events – and Eventbrite allows people to book as groups, organise seating together and share news of events they’re attending so that word of the event is amplified. According to data collected by the company, every time someone shares an Eventbrite event on Facebook it drives on average an additional $2.15 in ticket sales and 12 visits back to the site for the organiser. In February CEO, Kevin Hartz, labelled Ticketek a “dinosaur” and announced expansion plans in Australia.

 

Sephora – Hauling

Fragrance and cosmetics chain Sephora installed video facilities in store to encourage ‘hauling’ (video commentaries of items purchased on a shopping trip) from customers after checking out. Having taken off, particularly for the cosmetics and fashion categories, the brand continues to encourage the hauling trend by featuring fan videos on its official YouTube channel.

 

LocalResponse

LocalResponse, headquartered in New York City, is a social advertising platform that aggregates public posts and ‘check-ins’ across multiple platforms to help brands and businesses identify intent and respond to it. Targeting data, such as, behavioral, demographic or contextual is usually approximated. LocalResponse’s platform is able to identify where someone is, when they are there, and what they are saying about it. Marketers act on the consumer’s real-time intent by converting people with exclusive offers or coupons via mobile at point-of-sale.

 

 

User-generated content choking in Facebook’s overgrown garden

With the volume of content shared on Facebook having increased exponentially, not only is cut through for brands declining, but clicks on links shared by consumers have also plummeted, down 66% in the past year.

The finding, from a study of post-purchase shares on Facebook, comes as bad news for brands, in particular for retailers who are attempting to boost sales through ‘social commerce’ approaches that get consumers talking about products online or sharing links to retail sites.

The study, conducted on over 26,500 shares across multiple category verticals by social commerce platform Shopon, found that gaining traction from encouraged sharing of brand material, even when the share appears genuine and is in the consumer’s own words, is becoming increasingly difficult. Clicks on links posted to Facebook through Shopon’s platform, which incentivises customers to share products they’ve just bought as part of the post-checkout process, declined from 3.6 in May 2011 to 1.2 in May 2012.

Co-founder of Shopon and business development manager at digital agency Amblique, Andrew McCarthy, puts the cut-through challenge down to the wave of sharing buttons popping up across the web and services such as Spotify and social news readers.

“Facebook is telling us that more people are going on and sharing product and more people are engaging with their platform,” McCarthy explains. “They are, but that doesn’t mean [posts are] going to get more traction… the volume of content going through Facebook has increased exponentially in the past year.”

The May run of the study found that roughly 4% of people will share as part of the post-purchase process when offered an incentive, based on a sample of over 26,500 buyers who were offered a 15% discount coupon to share their purchase on Facebook. Of these, around 10,500 shared news of their purchase in their own words, driving almost 13,000 clicks back to the sites involved in the study and around 1100 sales.

Naturally, propensity to share was higher for some retail categories than others. The study picked out retailers in the electronics, pet supplies, fabric and fashion categories as examples. While average shares made to earn the discount coupon was 4%, the pet supplies category achieved shares from 10% of buyers.

McCarthy says the key to successful social commerce is finding areas where people have an affinity to share, but also getting the right people to share: “Social commerce is a game of psychology, not a game of technology. We can encourage them to share all we like but if they don’t think the topic defines them as a person then they’re not going to be inclined to share.”

People who have strong affinities around certain interests are both more likely to share and more likely to be influential when sharing about their interest, McCarthy adds. “When these type of people share through Facebook they have a greater conversion rate in driving people back through to the website.”

In order to get people to share their feelings on products, the reward for sharing, which could be a coupon or a social or emotional reward, has to be greater than the cost of openness and the effort required to complete the share.

The study also found that while it may be getting harder to cut through, social commerce performed well is highly valuable, and can drive much higher conversion rates than advertising.

 

Pinterest drives more ecommerce revenue than Facebook and Twitter

Brands using Pinterest to drive traffic to ecommerce sites are reaping the rewards, with the one-year-old social network already driving more revenue per click than Facebook and Twitter.

Analysis from Convertro, which tracks the marketing performance for its clients across various channels, including Facebook, Twitter and Pinterest, found that Pinterest was generating up to four times the revenue per click as Twitter and 27% more than Facebook.

The research found that Pinterest is the fastest growing social media traffic source for ecommerce websites in terms of revenue, having grown from 1.2% of social media revenue in quarter two of 2011 to 17.4% in quarter one of 2012.

Facebook currently makes up the vast majority at around 80%, a share that is projected to erode to 60% as Pinterest assumes 40% of traffic by the end of quarter two. Based on these projections, Twitter is expected to fade into insignificance on the social commerce scene.

Writing on technology blog VentureBeat, Jeffrey Zwelling from Convertro, says Pinterest tends to introduce new customers to client websites, making it a ‘top of funnel’ marketing source. He writes:

“If you measure the big three social media sites on a ‘first touch’ revenue per click basis, Pinterest is the clear winner.  Being first is good because it indicates that Pinterest tends to introduce customers to retailers, instead of simply reinforcing users’ previous interest in the site or providing a navigational method of getting to the site.”

First touch is measured by tracking referral traffic from these different sources and looking at what resulted in revenue. On this basis, Pinterest generates around $0.18 per click, over four times as much as Twitter and 27% more than Facebook.

On a multi-touch basis (giving credit to every marketing channel regardless of its position in the purchase funnel) Pinterest is still the most productive social media source for e-commerce sites, generating $0.45 per click compared to $0.40 for Facebook and $0.23 for Twitter.

Zwelling suggest that, at a minimum, etailers add the ‘Pinit’ button to each SKU on their website.

To see how brands have started using Pinterest, check out our Top10 uses of Pinterest by brands story for some inspiration for using the new social network.

Converting fans into customers

As 2011 winds down, and before the party season gets underway, it is worth putting time aside to take stock and plan for the the coming months. 2012 will see social media marketing shift gears in a big way. Now is the time to consider how to convert your social media ‘fans’ into customers.

Much has been discussed about return on investment (ROI) in the social media space. Some commentators say ROI needs to focus on areas like brand perception and customer satisfaction – but these are notoriously difficult measure accurately. While I agree that these areas need to be taken into consideration, not having well defined metrics and ignoring conversion goals simply makes no sense. In short, there needs to be clear alignment with the business objectives.

The great thing about social media is it allows you to capture vast quantities of demographic and psychometric data. This data can, and should, be used for targeted messaging. The segments you market to will be fairly broad to start with but will become increasingly granular over time. After testing the waters it will be possible to economically communicate to individuals with tailored messaging – messaging that understands the individual on a personal level.

You don’t always need a ‘hard sell’ approach to move potential customers down a sales conversion path. Sometimes it’s enough to show them that you know and care and are prepared to communicate on a personal level. In this ultra-personalised digital world, your market, particularly the segment that has grown up on the web, now expect everything to be personalised. In fact it is often the only way to get noticed.

A research report published in October this year from the Australian Centre of Retail Studies concluded that the more channels in which a consumer encounters a particular brand, the more likely they are to purchase and the higher their overall spend will be. The lesson here is not rocket science. Once you have used social media to develop your contact list, find out how to communicate with them via email, mobile, social media and your website. Get all the channels working together.

The final step on the conversion journey is the execution. Communicating in a customised way via multiple channels can be expensive if there is not a strong system sitting in the background. What’s more, these interactions in social media mean that you are never sure when someone will take the first step in the conversion cycle. Platforms like ExactTarget allow you to not only automate communications through many different channels, but also provide the necessary tools to refine the sales strategy as additional customer data flows in.

So it is possible to create an effective social media conversion strategy. Just remember to keep things simple and stay focused on what the customer wants.

The future of… social media

This feature first appeared in the December 2011/January 2012 issue of Marketing magazine.

 

As 2011 comes to an end, Marketing magazine decided to take a look at the most rapidly evolving channels. The pace of change across the industry made this a difficult decision, but the three we’ve analysed all share a common, and ever evolving, game-changer: technology.

In the first of our predictions trilogy, Matt Granfield looks at how social media and brands will meet in 2012.

Two years ago, social media was the future. Now, according to research by Nielsen, social networks and blogs are the top online destination for the world’s internet users, accounting for the majority of time spent online. Social media is bigger than porn. Social media is more popular than email.

As Brian Solis, principal at US research group Altimeter (and world-renowned social media guru), says: “We’re finally approaching the end of the hype curve.” So now is the time to start making sense of exactly what social media means for the future of business and media.

There are plenty of major brands in Australia that still don’t have a social media strategy, of course, but they’re lucky in a way, because for every company still wondering whether or not to open a Twitter account, there are two others who’ve already paved a path, made the mistakes and figured out how these new social channels can make a positive impact on a business’ bottom line.

In an effort to try and see the way forward for those still trying to catch up (read: nearly everyone), we decided to speak to some Australian online marketing and communications pioneers and ask them what they saw around the corner for the future of social media.

No one would challenge Telstra’s position as a digital marketing innovator in Australia. The region’s largest telco has typically been one of the first major corporations in our part of the world to embrace each social channel as it has emerged. It was blogging, tweeting, Facebooking, Flickring and YouTubing before most companies had figured out what LOL meant. Leading the charge as head of online communications and social media from 2009 until a couple of months ago, when she left the organisation to join PR agency Haystac, was Kristen Boschma. Her crystal ball sees marketers and communicators joining hands to get a whole lot more sophisticated in their use of the new technologies, in a whole range of new places we didn’t think social media could go.

“Up until now we’ve seen companies leverage social media in their marketing campaigns, but I think in the next 12 months what we’ll see is a real increase in sophistication and skill of corporate Australia embracing social media,” says Boschma. “In particular, we’ll see a real increase in social CRM and a much greater knowledge of our customers’ buying habits, and using social media to analyse consumption habits. I also think we’ll get a lot more sophisticated in terms of leveraging our PR and our marketing efforts and bringing them all into alignment, so we’ve got a more consistent approach and a more consistent brand view.”

She also thinks consumers will really start to define how they use each channel and will demand platforms that allow them to really segment the various communities with which they engage.

“I think Google has been really smart with its creation of circles, because I think conceptually that’s how consumers are going to start to view social media in terms of ‘that’s a distinct community I belong to, and I behave this way on that channel, with these friends’, and they might view a different channel as a completely different community and they might engage with that community with a completely different persona,” says Boschma.

“The strength of any new social network has to be measured on the habits it forms. For example, Facebook has changed the way we use the internet, full stop. It has changed the way we engage with our friends on a personal level. If I look at Google Plus and the huddle approach it has taken to video conferencing, I think that has really powerful implications for the way companies can market to consumers, in terms of bringing them into their inner circle, making the interaction with the company real. Companies will start saying, ‘We’re going to have a hangout now with the ice-cream flavour development department. Come and hang out with us and tell us what you think’, or ‘Come and see what happens at Sunrise (the Channel Seven breakfast program) in between the ad breaks and find out what really goes on’. Bringing consumers into your corporate hangouts and making them much more a part of the organisation, and the inner workings of your organisation, is a really interesting idea.”

Beyond innovations around video conferencing, Boschma says people can also expect social media to start reaching out to them in places that have traditionally been social, but not necessarily connected.

“If we’re talking beyond 12 months, what’s going to be really interesting, and we’re starting to see the signs of it already, is social media in completely different environments. At the moment it’s all about PCs and smartphones and tablets, but a couple of years down the track, social media will be reaching your lounge room via your TV, or your car via your stereo. That’s going to give social media the power to be pervasive on multiple, multiple channels,” she says.

Over in the banking world, it may still be a while before you can check your credit card balance on your subwoofer, but NAB (National Australia Bank) and the Commonwealth Bank have been introducing a number of innovations in the way customers can interact with the organisations and find consumer-generated opinions of their products. The Commonwealth Bank introduced an online chat function in 2009, which allows customers to initiate an online chat with call centre staff. This technology hooked into the existing call centre queue management software and allows for intelligent routing of requests to specific call centre groups. It’s not rocket science, but it was an important step forward in online engagement for an industry that has more stringent online security issues than any other sector (except perhaps for defence).

In another interesting move, NAB recently became the first Australian bank to adopt what it dubbed ‘social commerce’ on its website to assist customers in the online buying process.

Since October, NAB has been displaying customer ratings and reviews of its credit card products online to provide useful feedback to potential customers to help them make better decisions about which products might suit them.

NAB’s general manager of digital, direct banking, Chris Smith, says that the bank’s focus is on improving relationships with customers and making changes to offer Australians better alternatives.

“Social feedback has a big and growing influence on purchase decisions, and reviews by other NAB customers will provide valuable, independent feedback for those considering an NAB credit card,” he says.

Smith believes that the reviews will also help existing customers get more out of their products and learn about features of which they previously were unaware. Importantly, the feedback will be used to give NAB insight on what customers like about their credit cards and highlight areas for changes and improvements. To date, NAB has received more than 360 customer ratings and reviews on seven of its credit cards.

Consumer ratings aren’t a new concept, of course. TripAdvisor, amazon.com and countless other ecommerce platforms and review websites have been socialising opinions for more than a decade, but, like NAB, big businesses are only just starting to get more perspective on the wider business potential of what Karalee Evans, digital communications pioneer, senior director and APAC digital strategist at public relations firm Text 100, calls ‘the collaborative consumption of information online.’

“We’re looking at collaborative wikis that are popping up where people are taking ownership of the sharing of information,” says Evans.

“It’s the TripAdvisor model, but we’re starting to see it for sectors such as health and education. MySchool is the government example of where people can collaborate and network based on how their school is performing. They can talk to each other and find out information about a school’s arts program, or its sports program.”

Evans, who counts Optus, IBM, Fuji Xerox Australia and Yahoo!7 as clients, says the smartest companies are chopping down their silos and using social platforms to let different departments engage with each other.

“The businesses that will be competitive in tomorrow’s markets are the ones that can adapt to change and take a whole of business approach to collaboration and social media, not just from the marketing or PR department,” she says.

“CMOs need to be talking to their CTOs. Businesses need to remove the silos of their departments and start to ensure that they’re collaborating and sharing business intelligence. And that’s where the concept of ‘big data’ comes in – getting companies to use and analyse everything they know about their customers across all departments. Businesses need to understand how their consumers are behaving, where they’re going and start to forecast what the trends are.

“They need to trust their agencies as well, and the strategists in those agencies need to be on top of the trends and making really frank and fearless recommendations about what businesses should be doing – and they’re going to either sink or swim based on those recommendations,” argues Evans.

Which is all well and good if you’re IBM or NAB, but what if you’re over on the other side of the business spectrum, wondering how you can do something as simple as making your Facebook page a little more engaging or profitable?

Zac Martin, digital strategist at George Patterson Y&R in Melbourne, sums up the future of social media at the smaller end of town.

“With social media, notoriously dull and dry brands have been given a personal and sometimes even likeable voice that consumers can talk with directly,” says Martin.

“Throw some excellent social media customer service, where I haven’t had to sit on hold for 20 minutes – that I’ve experienced recently – and for me, at the moment, these are the guys who are crushing it in this space.

“The best thing brands can do moving forward is to provide that old marketing chestnut: value. There are too many brands at the moment focusing on pointless things like getting as many ‘Likes’ as possible on a status update. As more and more brands jump online, consumers are going to become more selective about who they like/follow/subscribe to, and the brands who write shitty status updates that don’t actually have any value… will be the first to go.”

 

This article is featured in the December/January issue of Marketing magazine.